There's No England Now...

[Meh Gerbil]

I was going to school The Carrot(tm) but I see it has been handled.
You got off easy, Carrot.

[Darth Executor]

Genetic fallacy.

More importantly, one of the reasons I respect teh Gerbil is that unlike many here, he doesn't refrain from pointing out flaws in the arguments of those with whom he generally agrees.

You should gun down flawed arguments that support your own view - because they turn away those who might otherwise be persuaded.

Gerbil isn't gunning down any arguments, good or bad. He's gunning down anyone who fights for that particular issue, period. I haven't seen him interact with any actual arguments on the subject even once.