Plantinga Changed His Mind

[whag]

Many birth defects are caused by mutation, and many mutations are caused by copying errors, yes. Why should such mutations be designed? Designing an error is incoherent.

Are you different from your parents?

[Paprika]

Are you different from your parents?

Genetically, yes.

[whag]

Genetically, yes.

And to what is that due?

[OingoBoingo]

Getting the facts straight would involve reading about the goings-on within the movement. Who reads the about section at YouTube? The video is about The Problem with TE, not Behe's and Dembski's foggy accommodation of evolution they've yet to coherently explain. What do you think it was about?

Weak come back. Just admit when you're wrong about something and move on. Its not the end of the world.

[Paprika]

And to what is that due?

The gametes carrying one chromosome set each.

[whag]

Weak come back. Just admit when you're wrong about something and move on. Its not the end of the world.

You're not getting me. Is there any theistically significant dividing line between mutations and other factors that cause variance? I haven't heard that explained coherently.

[Paprika]

You're not getting me. Is there any theistically significant dividing line between mutations and other factors that cause variance? I haven't heard that explained coherently.

First, understand that mutations have different causes.

[OingoBoingo]

You're not getting me. Is there any theistically significant dividing line between mutations and other factors that cause variance? I haven't heard that explained coherently.

You're not getting it. I don't care. That has nothing to do with why I replied to your post #62, and you know it. Damn, you're as bad as shunyadragon.

[whag]

First, understand that mutations have different causes.

Check. I'm listening.

[Paprika]

Check. I'm listening.

Right, now please explain why there should be a cause for concern.

[whag]

You're not getting it. I don't care. That has nothing to do with why I replied to your post #62, and you know it. Damn, you're as bad as shunyadragon.

Don't respond to the ID discussion then? I gather you want to participate.

[OingoBoingo]

Don't respond to the ID discussion then? I gather you want to participate.

I think its hilarious that every time I call you out, you ask me to stop posting.

[whag]

Right, now please explain why there should be a cause for concern.

No coherent distinction between positive variance and variance that challenges survival. Weak genes are passed on as much as strong genes, or am I missing something?

I'm not Francis Collins, to be sure. I'll stand corrected if this is not a point.

[Paprika]

No coherent distinction between positive variance and variance that challenges survival. Weak genes are passed on as much as strong genes, or am I missing something?

I really don't get what you're getting at. Is this supposed to be a problem with the biology or how it would fit in a Christian worldview?

[whag]

I think its hilarious that every time I call you out, you ask me to stop posting.

On the contrary, I want you to participate. I've invited you to discuss this many times.

You called me out for not reading an about section that doesn't explain what the video is about. Watching the video is the best method for determining what it's about.