�INSULTING TO ISLAM� Thousands of Muslims demand Nike recall �offensive� Air Max trai

[Sparko]

Oh, I agree. But to claim "Breivik isn't a Christian, he doesn't believe in God. He's stated so quite clearly multiple times, including in his manifesto" when Breivik's manifesto clearly states that he is a Christian and does believe in God is exactly the form of denial I meant.

I thought CP's initial point was anyone doing such things as terrorism would be denounced loudly as not representing Christianity? Isn't that clearly what Christians have done? I don't understand your objection.

[Mountain Man]

I thought CP's initial point was anyone doing such things as terrorism would be denounced loudly as not representing Christianity? Isn't that clearly what Christians have done? I don't understand your objection.

I'm not even certain Ignorant Roy understands his own objection.

[Cow Poke]

I'm not even certain Ignorant Roy understands his own objection.

I think he has decided that our main response to alleged Christians committing violence is --- don't denounce the violence, just deny they're Christians.

Roy really is smarter than this. I'm thinking he just messed up and can't bring himself to admit it.

[One Bad Pig]

Well let me denounce him for you. He does not represent Christianity, he is a terrorist. Christianity in no way teaches mass murder of innocents.

Let's make that a little broader. Christianity is so far from teaching that murder is licit that even hating someone is condemned as murder.

[Cow Poke]

Let's make that a little broader. Christianity is so far from teaching that murder is licit that even hating someone is condemned as murder.

When we were little kids, I got really upset at one of my sisters, and yelled "I hate your guts!"

She just smiled and said, "you CAN'T hate me!"

I said, "Oh YEAH, why not?"

She said, "Cause the Jesus in you can't hate the Jesus in me".


(yeah, I wasn't showing much 'Jesus' then)

[Mountain Man]

When we were little kids, I got really upset at one of my sisters, and yelled "I hate your guts!"

She just smiled and said, "you CAN'T hate me!"

I said, "Oh YEAH, why not?"

She said, "Cause the Jesus in you can't hate the Jesus in me".


(yeah, I wasn't showing much 'Jesus' then)

It reminds me of the story of the guy sitting down to talk to his pastor about his marital problems:

"I don't love my wife any more."
"But the Bible says to love your wife."
"Well, she's more of just a friend than a wife these days."
"The Bible says to love your friends."
"Well, maybe not so much friends. We're more like neighbors."
"The Bible says to love your neighbor."
"Okay, you know what? She's like an enemy to me!"
"The Bible says to love your enemy."

[Sparko]

I think he has decided that our main response to alleged Christians committing violence is --- don't denounce the violence, just deny they're Christians.

Roy really is smarter than this. I'm thinking he just messed up and can't bring himself to admit it.

Well naturally if someone calls themselves a Christian and does things so horrendously against what Christianity teaches then they are not Christians. We would denounce both the action and them. They might claim themselves as Christian but they clearly are not. Like Timothy McVeigh (the Oklahoma city bomber) he belonged to a white supremacist Christian Identity movement - which clearly is a heretical cult.

He tried to pull the same thing on me with the Jehovah's Witnesses when I said they were not Christian.

[JimL]

wow...

So what, you know how touchy the religious can be. AXE Deoderant had to ban their commercial because christians were offended that Angels were descending from heaven because they were attracted to a mans deoderant.

[One Bad Pig]

So what, you know how touchy the religious can be. AXE Deoderant had to ban their commercial because christians were offended that Angels were descending from heaven because they were attracted to a mans deoderant.

I've somehow managed to never hear of this before now. All people can be touchy. Carpe, an avowed atheist, tries his best not to handle actual money because it says, "In God We Trust" on it.

[oxmixmudd]

I've somehow managed to never hear of this before now. All people can be touchy. Carpe, an avowed atheist, tries his best not to handle actual money because it says, "In God We Trust" on it.

How in the world did this thread get moved to 'the padded room'? Sheesh, nearly every thread in Civics or Nat Sci should be in 'the padded room' if this thread qualifies.

Jim

[One Bad Pig]

How in the world did this thread get moved to 'the padded room'? Sheesh, nearly every thread in Civics or Nat Sci should be in 'the padded room' if this thread qualifies.

Jim

A moderator intended to move a few posts to the padded room, and something went kablooey. We're looking into it.

[DesertBerean]

A moderator intended to move a few posts to the padded room, and something went kablooey. We're looking into it.

Yeah and it should be fixed now.

[Roy]

I think he has decided that our main response to alleged Christians committing violence is --- don't denounce the violence, just deny they're Christians.

It's what I've observed.

The usual response to Christians committing violence is to deny that the perpetrators are Christians. Not to admit that they are Christians that have sinned or erred or otherwise fallen short of expectations, or that they are Christians who have different views on how Christians should act, but to deny they are Christians.

There are several examples in this thread, and more in the threads I linked to.

[One Bad Pig]

It's what I've observed.

The usual response to Christians committing violence is to deny that the perpetrators are Christians. Not to admit that they are Christians that have sinned or erred or otherwise fallen short of expectations, or that they are Christians who have different views on how Christians should act, but to deny they are Christians.

There are several examples in this thread, and more in the threads I linked to.

Self-proclaimed Odinists are not Christians, Roy. As for the others.... A view countenancing acts condemned by specifically Christian scripture is not merely "different" - it is unChristian. They may claim Christianity, but they are not following its teachings. They've also been roundly condemned by pretty much every Christian community consulted. Imagining that this is anything like the case with Islam is like deliberately ignoring the forest in favor of a tree or two.
Much like the Pharisees, you manage to strain out gnats while swallowing a camel.

[Cow Poke]

It's what I've observed.

Perhaps because that's what you were wanting to see?