London Police; You Look Jewish...

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

If there was a concern that this "legal protest" was a threat to the man's safety simply because he appeared to be Jewish, then it was a mob.

If anyone tried to cut directly through a large demonstration it would cause problems.

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

Pot meet kettle...

I do not see this issue through your bigotry of Jews all good & Arabs all bad.

[seer]

I do not see this issue through your bigotry of Jews all good & Arabs all bad.

Where did I say that all Arabs are bad? I personally know a number of Christian Arabs. I do believe that all of Hamas and probably most of the PA are bad. I mean look at how they treat their own people - they won't even let them vote, and there are no human rights.

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

Where did I say that all Arabs are bad? I personally know a number of Christian Arabs.

Ah! Only Muslim Arabs are bad.

Although those Christian Arabs you know may be anti-Semitic. It has a long history in Christianity.

[Roy]

If the policeman was just wandering around London and walked up to a Jewish person and said "you look Jewish, you shouldn't be in public, I'll arrest you if you don't go away", then absolutely yes, that would be anti-Semitism and totally unacceptable.

Threatening to arrest someone for looking Jewish is something I can see you supporting and excusing it because it wasn't his physical appearance but his attire.

You appear to be responding to your imagination, not to what was written.

I guess it was just my imagination then that the officer told him that "you are quite openly Jewish" and threatened him with arrest if he didn't leave.

No, it was your imagination that concocted something Starlight didn't say.

I'm not citing star but rather what H_A posted, ...

I've reconstructed the conversation to show that you were actually responding to Starlight (or rather to what you imaged he would say), and were not originally citing H_A at all, that's just an excuse for not having to defend what you wrote. .

Perhaps you should be more concerned with your honesty first.

My honesty is fine.

Yours clearly is not.

[seer]

Ah! Only Muslim Arabs are bad.

I was very specific wasn't I? The leadership. And BTW I deal with Muslims in my field every day. For years my GP and Dentist were Muslims (immigrated from Iran).

[Roy]

1) What anti-Semitism?
2) That appears to have been Mr Falter's intent.

Start trouble how? Was he going to attack the protestors? Say something untoward? Heaven forbid.

You didn't answer the question: what anti-Semitism?

(I won't pretend that not answering means you agree there wasn't any. I leave such dishonest tactics to you)

[Roy]

Yes, the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate it was a lie.

1) The Grauniad article cited upthread stated that Mr Falter tried to cross the protest route from both sides, heading both north and south. That's not consistent with him simply heading homewards.
2) I don't have to prove something is false in the absence of any evidence that it is true.
3) You aren't mossrose.

[Mountain Man]

If anyone tried to cut directly through a large demonstration it would cause problems.

Especially if they looked Jewish, right?

[CivilDiscourse]

Ah! Only Muslim Arabs are bad.

Although those Christian Arabs you know may be anti-Semitic. It has a long history in Christianity.

Look at that quote mine.

[seer]

You didn't answer the question: what anti-Semitism?

(I won't pretend that not answering means you agree there wasn't any. I leave such dishonest tactics to you)

Chants from the 'river to the sea.'

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

Especially if they looked Jewish, right?

Would they? Who knows!

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

I was very specific wasn't I? The leadership. And BTW I deal with Muslims in my field every day. For years my GP and Dentist were Muslims (immigrated from Iran).

You have completely destroyed your own regular allegations.

You have repeatedly referred to those of us here who have defended the Palestinian people against abuses by Israel as anti-Semites, Jew haters, and Hamas supporters

However, you are not a rational individual.

[seer]

You have completely destroyed your own regular allegations.

You have repeatedly referred to those of us here who have defended the Palestinian people against abuses by Israel as anti-Semites, Jew haters, and Hamas supporters

However, you are not a rational individual.

No, you completely missed the point. You are a Jew hater because you only condemn the Jews and never the Muslims (post after post, thread after thread). You never take the side of the Jew but always take the side of the Jew haters - those who want to destroy the JEWISH state. You are a Jew hater HA, down in your bones. Perhaps it has to do with your Nazi heritage.

[Mountain Man]

Would they? Who knows!

You're certainly acting like you know.