Liberal Death Culture

[Sparko]

The idiocy of that comment sums you up very well indeed.

I knew you were going to type that.

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

I knew you were going to type that.

Is playtime still ongoing?

[Sparko]

Is playtime still ongoing?

Not until you answer my question about jumping off a bridge.

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

Not until you answer my question about jumping off a bridge.

?

[rogue06]

?

Her problems are all related to mental conditions that cause her to want to die. There is nothing wrong with her health otherwise. You never answered my question.

If you were under a delusion that jumping off a bridge would allow you to fly, should your doctors try to stop you or help you find a suitable bridge? It's your life after all.

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

Is playtime still ongoing?

Not until you answer my question about jumping off a bridge.

?

[rogue06]

Her problems are all related to mental conditions that cause her to want to die. There is nothing wrong with her health otherwise. You never answered my question.

If you were under a delusion that jumping off a bridge would allow you to fly, should your doctors try to stop you or help you find a suitable bridge? It's your life after all.

I'm only replying for the mangy pirate because he rarely posts on weekends.

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

I'm only replying for the mangy pirate because he rarely posts on weekends.

I suggest we let him explain his rather bizarre reply to my question about playtime being ongoing.

[Sparko]

I suggest we let him explain his rather bizarre reply to my question about playtime being ongoing.

Stop dodging my question. It only shows you know that it exposes your hypocrisy here and that is why you won't answer.

If you were under a delusion that jumping off a bridge would allow you to fly, should your doctors try to stop you or help you find a suitable bridge?

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

Stop dodging my question. It only shows you know that it exposes your hypocrisy here and that is why you won't answer.

If you were under a delusion that jumping off a bridge would allow you to fly, should your doctors try to stop you or help you find a suitable bridge?

I am still waiting for you to state whether or not if it is the individual who has sole and ultimate authority over their life.

For Mr Thirumalesh, who had mental issues, you considered that she did.

For Ms ter Beek who also has mental issues you consider that she does not.

[Sparko]

I am still waiting for you to state whether or not if it is the individual who has sole and ultimate authority over their life.

For Mr Thirumalesh, who had mental issues, you considered that she did.

For Ms ter Beek who also has mental issues you consider that she does not.

I answered you several times. Only God has ultimate control over our lives. We do not have the right to take our own lives. Suicide is a sin. If we don't have the right to end our own lives, neither does the state have the right to assist us in that endeavor.

I suspect you will never answer my question ( If you were under a delusion that jumping off a bridge would allow you to fly, should your doctors try to stop you or help you find a suitable bridge? )
because you recognize that the only way you can be consistent is to say "Yes, they should help you find a suitable bridge" - yet, you recognize that would be the wrong answer. If you admitted that they should not help you jump off a bridge because of your mental illness, then they should not be helping this young lady commit suicide because of her mental illness.

[One Bad Pig]

I suggest we let him explain his rather bizarre reply to my question about playtime being ongoing.

It is amusing to watch you studiously avoid answering his question.

[rogue06]

I suggest we let him explain his rather bizarre reply to my question about playtime being ongoing.

And you still wouldn't answer it when he asked.

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

I answered you several times. Only God has ultimate control over our lives. We do not have the right to take our own lives

Suicide is a sin. If we don't have the right to end our own lives, neither does the state have the right to assist us in that endeavor..

In your opinion. However, I daresay you make exceptions when it comes to the "ultimate control" over "lives". Unless of course you are a complete pacifist.

I suspect you will never answer my question ( If you were under a delusion that jumping off a bridge would allow you to fly, should your doctors try to stop you or help you find a suitable bridge? )
because you recognize that the only way you can be consistent is to say "Yes, they should help you find a suitable bridge" - yet, you recognize that would be the wrong answer. If you admitted that they should not help you jump off a bridge because of your mental illness, then they should not be helping this young lady commit suicide because of her mental illness.

It is her life, just as you contended repeatedly that it was Ms Thiramalesh's life and that she had the ultimate control over it.

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

And you still wouldn't answer it when he asked.

His question is a distraction. If, as several of you contended at the time, that Ms Thirumalesh should have had the ultimate control over her life, it follows that so does Ms ter Beek,

However, it is been made apparent that, insofar as several of you are concerned, personal autonomy only applies when the individual's wishes coincide with your own viewpoints.