Lost your password? Questions? Email admin @ theologyweb.com
If you are having trouble logging into Tweb, make sure you check the box labeled "Remember me" below the password field.
Announcement
Collapse
Philosophy 201 Guidelines
Cogito ergo sum
Here in the Philosophy forum we will talk about all the "why" questions. We'll have conversations about the way in which philosophy and theology and religion interact with each other. Metaphysics, ontology, origins, truth? They're all fair game so jump right in and have some fun! But remember...play nice!
You have to realize that it is an object, that the object is not you which requires a sense of self, that things outside of yourself exist, that it gives off light, that it is not close by, that you can't eat it.
An intelligent, reasoning entity will understand these things. This is not to say that creatures of limited intelligence will not be aware of them to some extent. It's not an 'all or nothing' thing, it's graduated.
.. the more intelligent the brain the more realizations come into play.
True, but at the bottom end of the spectrum a creature such as a wolf will still howl at the moon with virtually none of these realizations.
An intelligent, reasoning entity will understand these things. This is not to say that creatures of limited intelligence will not be aware of them to some extent. It's not an 'all or nothing' thing, it's graduated.
True, but at the bottom end of the spectrum a creature such as a wolf will still howl at the moon with virtually none of these realizations.
The wolf has most of those realizations. It is aware that the moon is a far away object that is not part of itself, that it isn't food or something it can eat, that it gives off light.
They aren't aware Tassman. they merely react. You could program a robot to do the same thing. It is just a biological machine that has programmed responses to stimuli. It isn't aware of anything.
Awareness requires at least rudimentary consciousness which requires a sophisticated brain.
The wolf has most of those realizations. It is aware that the moon is a far away object that is not part of itself, that it isn't food or something it can eat, that it gives off light.
Are you arguing that the wolf is reasoning "that the moon is a far away object that is not part of itself, that it isn't food or something it can eat, that it gives off light". I don't think so. The most one can say that the wolf is aware of the moon and reacts by baying at it.
that the object is not you which requires a sense of self,
When a kitten looks in the mirror it is aware of the object it see's there, but it is not aware that the object it see's is it's self. Why? Because observation is not the same as reasoning.
that things outside of yourself exist, that it gives off light, that it is not close by, that you can't eat it...the more intelligent the brain the more realizations come into play.
They don't have to realize all those things about the moon in order to observe it's existence.
No they don't Shuny. Reflexes work without awareness. If that weren't the case you would have suffocated long ago as soon as you fell asleep, or have gone blind because your pupils did not adjust to bright light.
Jellyfish are "hardwired" - there is no "software"
Are you arguing that the wolf is reasoning "that the moon is a far away object that is not part of itself, that it isn't food or something it can eat, that it gives off light". I don't think so. The most one can say that the wolf is aware of the moon and reacts by baying at it.
The wolf has no language, but he can reason. You don't see wolves trying to eat the moon or attack it do you? Why not? And the whole "wolf baying at the moon" is a trope.
When a kitten looks in the mirror it is aware of the object it see's there, but it is not aware that the object it see's is it's self. Why? Because observation is not the same as reasoning.
They don't have to realize all those things about the moon in order to observe it's existence.
A kitten will think the reflection is another kitten. He is reasoning, just incorrectly. Observation requires awareness which requires some level of reasoning. It doesn't have to be verbal reasoning. It does require a brain though.
The wolf has no language, but he can reason. You don't see wolves trying to eat the moon or attack it do you? Why not? And the whole "wolf baying at the moon" is a trope.
You are projecting. A wolf is aware of the moon and howls at it instinctively. It not reasoning about it being "a far away object that is not part of itself", etc. etc.etc.
You are projecting. A wolf is aware of the moon and howls at it instinctively. It not reasoning about it being "a far away object that is not part of itself", etc. etc.etc.
Wolves can reason quite well Tassman. Ever watch a dog standing on something high and trying to decide if it can jump down or not? They are aware of distance and objects.
Wolves can reason quite well Tassman. Ever watch a dog standing on something high and trying to decide if it can jump down or not? They are aware of distance and objects.
So what are wolves reasoning about when they howl at the moon?
Comment