An obstetrician's opinion

[Cow Poke]

Apparently H_A never heard of much less experienced a business dinner.

And she clearly ignored several posts where it was CLEAR it wasn't "just dinner".

And you probably ignored the part where I actually had dinner Tuesday night with lawyers from the Office of Attorney General of Texas where we discussed this case.

You've been around a lot longer than me, but, seriously --- I have never seen such an outright .

[rogue06]

Yes, she seems quite adept at killing babies. You have shown ZERO evidence that she has any training or certifications in Texas law.

There is no indication that she even read the law given some of her mischaracterizations much less has any training or certifications

[Gondwanaland]

Your appeals to status may have an impact on others, but they fail with me.

Unless it's someone like the bimbo in the OP who agrees with you, then you lap it up.

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

You seem to be reveling in your stupidity.

Just pointing out a fact. that everyone offering their legal opinion is unqualified.

[Cow Poke]

I have made no appeal to her status.

She is a qualified medical professional with experience of high risk pregnancies.

Almost in the same breath!!!

[Gondwanaland]

I made reference to her medical qualifications, which you appear to consider have no bearing on any potential maternal health issue[including foetal abnormalities] that may arise in Texas in the future.

When she displays that she has no clue what the law in Texas actually says, yes, her medical qualifications have no bearing. Had she actually read the law and shown that she knew what it says instead of fabricating fantasies of mercenaries, she might have some bearing on the situation. As it is, you just did another appeal to status which you claim you haven't done.

[Cow Poke]

Just pointing out a fact.

No, you're ignoring facts right and left.

that everyone offering their legal opinion is unqualified.

Having been trained in Texas law, I am FAR more qualified in offering my legal opinion than a BabyKiller Doctor from New York or a Crazy Cat Lady from Germany, NEITHER of whom can even READ the Texas Law.

[Gondwanaland]

She is an authority in her own discipline

That does not automatically and unquestioningly guarantee that she is in any way competent.

and how this Bill may impact on women in Texas who suffer similar problems.

Er, no, she made it quite clear that she doesn't have a Scooby what the law in Texas says, so she cannot remotely be considered an authority in how the bill (that she hasn't read - that or she lied flagrantly about: your choice) may impact women in Texas who 'suffer similar problems'.

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

H_A as a judge: What qualifications do you have that makes you an expert in this area.


Expert Witness: I have a PhD in the pertinent field and wrote my dissertation on this very subject. Since then I've written over 20 peer-reviewed papers on this topic and have taught a post-graduate class on it for the last decade at one of the nation's top universities.

Is that a claim for yourself? Or Cow Poke?

[Hypatia_Alexandria]

Unless you all want to continue playing ad infinitum I think this thread has run its course and comments are merely going around in circles.

Could a moderator consider closing it?

[Cow Poke]

Unless you all want to continue playing ad infinitum I think this thread has run its course and comments are merely going around in circles.

Could a moderator consider closing it?

I think it would be an EXCELLENT idea to close this thread, having exposed your gross incompetence and misrepresentations of the Texas Heartbeat Bill.
Same with your "Bounty Hunter" thread.

[CivilDiscourse]

Unless you all want to continue playing ad infinitum I think this thread has run its course and comments are merely going around in circles.

Could a moderator consider closing it?

Someone's taking thier ball again.

[Cow Poke]

Moderated By: CP

Thread closed at owner's request

***If you wish to take issue with this notice DO NOT do so in this thread.***
Contact the forum moderator or an administrator in Private Message or email instead. If you feel you must publicly complain or whine, please take it to the Padded Room unless told otherwise.