1. Necessary truths exist.
2. The law of identity (A=A) is a necessary truth.
3. Necessary truths are true in all possible worlds.
4. Such propositions are mind dependent.
5. Human minds are contingent, they are not necessary in all possible worlds, therefore the propositions they harbor can not traverse all possible worlds..
6. An eternal transcendent Mind would accommodate necessary truths in all possible worlds.
7. Therefore an eternal transcendent Mind is necessary for such truths to exist in all possible worlds.
2. The law of identity (A=A) is a necessary truth.
3. Necessary truths are true in all possible worlds.
4. Such propositions are mind dependent.
5. Human minds are contingent, they are not necessary in all possible worlds, therefore the propositions they harbor can not traverse all possible worlds..
6. An eternal transcendent Mind would accommodate necessary truths in all possible worlds.
7. Therefore an eternal transcendent Mind is necessary for such truths to exist in all possible worlds.
Comment